Compare Hotels on the Lake in Long Island

"I enjoyed the quietness and the charm. Very relaxing. Excellent staff."

"Amazing staff and location. Rooms were very clean and spacious. Service was spectacular and we will definitely be returning."

"The check in process was efficient, staff were cordial and professional. The property was very well maintained, colorful and clean. I loved my rental and my experience at this property. "

"The property is was perfect for us and was just as advertised. And the view from the unit was out of this world. Stunning. The owners get an A for their attentiveness and helpfulness on many fronts. They could write the book on being good VRBO hosts!"

"I love how the prices were so affrodable in th gift shop and on the property. We were able to rent a car there as well"

"This property is absolutely beautiful! Hardly anyone on the beach, very laid back. Not everything is perfect, our safe didn't work, could only lock door from inside villa, they didn't have the proper tip to inflate our floaties, but you have to remember you are in a remote area. You also have to remember you are on island time!! No one is in a hurry. We loved this place and will be back."