Compare Historic Hotels in Long Island
Secret Bargains - Save an extra 10% or more on select Historic Hotels
Get more for your budget and save up to 50% off select Secret Bargain hotels
Get even more value with CheapTickets Price Guarantee!
Change your flight without a fee on select flights
Featured Long Island Historic Hotels
Gems at Paradise Beach Hotel
Lochabar, Clarence Town, Long Island
The price is $222 per night
$222
includes taxes & fees
$203 per night
Jan 1 - Jan 2, 2025
With a stay at Gems at Paradise Beach Hotel in Clarence Town, you'll be 6.1 mi (9.8 km) from Dean's Blue Hole and 11 mi (17.7 km) from Buckley's Settlement Church.
On private beach
Parking included
Stella Maris Resort Club
Ocean View Drive, Stella Maris, Long Island
The price is $312 per night
$312
includes taxes & fees
$285 per night
Dec 23 - Dec 24
When you stay at Stella Maris Resort Club in Stella Maris, you'll be by the ocean and steps from Lucayan Archipelago.
On private beach
Spa
Cape Santa Maria Beach Resort
Li 30117 Queen Highway, Galliot Cay, Long Island
The price is $453 per night
$453
includes taxes & fees
$413 per night
Jan 8 - Jan 9, 2025
With a stay at Cape Santa Maria Beach Resort in Galliot Cay, you'll be on the beach, just a 1-minute walk from Lucayan Archipelago and 7 minutes by foot from Cape Santa Maria.
Spa
Parking included
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Long Island Historic Hotels essential information
Historic Hotels in Long Island |
3 |
---|---|
Highest price | $453 |
Cheapest price | $222 |
Total number of hotels in Long Island | 437 |
Popular hotels | Gems at Paradise Beach Hotel, Stella Maris Resort Club, Cape Santa Maria Beach Resort |
Most Recent Long Island Hotel Reviews
23Exuma * LUXURY, TOP BEACH* Calm Waters* 5 Bedrooms, Each w/Private Bath* Pool
5 out of 5
Posted 6 days ago
CheapTickets Verified Review
"There truly can't be a more perfect place to stay in the Caribbean, let alone on Exuma. This is our 4th visit to Exuma, and without a doubt, this is the best home we've rented. It is pristine and stocked with everything you could possibly need—right down to an electric corkscrew! The beach is the calmest and most beautiful on the island. We celebrated a memorable 60th birthday here, and it was fantastic. We highly recommend Chef Keva, Betty’s food delivery, and Jackie's pizza. We've already booked for 2025 and can’t wait to return. Many thanks to Dave and Yvonne for their excellent communication, and to the property manager, Andrew who checked in regularly to ensure everything was perfect. Highly, highly recommend!"
A verified traveler stayed at 23Exuma * LUXURY, TOP BEACH* Calm Waters* 5 Bedrooms, Each w/Private Bath* Pool
More Historic Hotels
Types of Hotels
Hotels Near Long Island
Cities near Long Island
More to Explore in Long Island
Top Picks
Hotels
Cheap Hotels in Bimini IslandsHotels in Downtown Washington D.C.Hotels in Bur DubaiHotels around Sawgrass MillsCheap Hotels in MundakayamSpa Resorts & Hotels in SabaCheap Hotels in LaredoCheap Hotels in Cannon BeachCheap Hotels in Bay HarborCheap Hotels in Mayaguana IslandCheap Hotels in Ormond Beach
Flights
Flights from Toronto to IslamabadFlights from Louisville to Daytona BeachFlights from Dallas to ChicagoFlights from Charlotte to ChicagoFlights from Las Vegas to Puerto PeñascoFlights to PhilippinesFlights to St. Croix IslandFlights from Houston to LondonFlights from Seattle to SacramentoFlights from Milwaukee to Phoenix