This is a spectacular building, as most old train stations were/are. Room was very comfortable, clean and quiet. Nice view of the common area (4th floor) with quick hourly "shows" on the water. Climate control worked as we wanted (which is unusual for us), warm while awake and nice and cool while sleeping.
There were a couple of things I could grumble a little bit about, but certainly no show stoppers. Parking is ridiculously expensive considering the premium money spent for, well, everything associated with the venue. I would like to see validation for guests, especially if they are booked for multiple nights. Also, I do wish that there were two chairs in the room for the table instead of one comfy chair and an office chair. And please clean the windows. The view is just too cool to be looking through a dirty window.
Altogether the verdict is yes, we would stay there again, and recommend it to others.