See all properties

The Madison Fire Island Pines

3.0 star property

Choose dates to view prices

your current months are December, 2024 and January, 2025.
December 2024
January 2025

Photo gallery for The Madison Fire Island Pines

Exterior
Lounge
Luxury Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Penthouse Bedroom B)
Exterior
Deluxe Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Penthouse Bedroom A)

Reviews

8.6 out of 10

Excellent

Popular amenities

  • Pool
    Pool
  • Free WiFi
    Free WiFi

Explore the area

Map
22 Atlantic Walk, Sayville, NY, 11782
  • Carrington House
    12 min walk
  • Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre
    26 min walk
  • Sailors' Haven
    41 min walk
  • Islip, NY (ISP-MacArthur)

Room options

View all photos for Deluxe Double Room, Private Bathroom, Garden View (Madison Bedroom A)

Deluxe Double Room, Private Bathroom, Garden View (Madison Bedroom A)

Deluxe Double Room, Private Bathroom, Garden View (Madison Bedroom A)

  • Sleeps 2

View all photos for Superior Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Garden Bedroom B)

Room

Superior Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Garden Bedroom B)

  • Sleeps 2

View all photos for Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Garden Bedroom A)

Room

Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Garden Bedroom A)

  • Sleeps 2

View all photos for Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Dexter Bedroom B)

Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Dexter Bedroom B)

Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Dexter Bedroom B)

  • Sleeps 2

View all photos for Premium Double Room, Private Bathroom, Garden View (Dexter Bedroom A)

Premium Double Room, Private Bathroom, Garden View (Dexter Bedroom A)

Premium Double Room, Private Bathroom, Garden View (Dexter Bedroom A)

  • Sleeps 2

View all photos for Standard Single Room, Private Bathroom (Madison Bedroom C)

Room

Standard Single Room, Private Bathroom (Madison Bedroom C)

  • Sleeps 2

View all photos for Standard Double Room, Private Bathroom (Madison Bedroom B)

Standard Double Room, Private Bathroom (Madison Bedroom B)

Standard Double Room, Private Bathroom (Madison Bedroom B)

  • Sleeps 2

View all photos for Luxury Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Penthouse Bedroom B)

Luxury Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Penthouse Bedroom B)

Luxury Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Penthouse Bedroom B)

  • Sleeps 2

View all photos for Deluxe Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Penthouse Bedroom A)

Deluxe Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Penthouse Bedroom A)

Deluxe Double Room, Private Bathroom, Pool View (Penthouse Bedroom A)

  • Sleeps 2
Front of property
Come As You Are Inn
Pool
Breakfast included
Free WiFi
Air conditioning
5.0 out of 5, Exceptional, (44)
The price is $180
per night
$206 total
includes taxes & fees
Dec 5 - Dec 6
Come As You Are Inn

About the neighborhood

Sayville

When you stay at The Madison Fire Island Pines in Sayville, you'll be within the region of Fire Island Lighthouse. .This guesthouse is within close proximity of Carrington House and Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre.
View more Guest Houses in SayvilleOpens in a new window

What's nearby

  • Carrington House - 12 min walk - 0.7 miles

Restaurants

  • ‪Blue Whale - ‬2 min walk
  • Kingston's Clam Bar
  • The Shed Restaurant - West Sayville NY
  • South Shore Dive
  • ‪Canteen - ‬1 min walk

About this property

The Madison Fire Island Pines

Adults-only guesthouse with a rooftop terrace and an outdoor pool
The Madison Fire Island Pines offers 9 accommodations.
Recreational amenities at the guesthouse include an outdoor pool.
Make yourself at home in one of the 9 guestrooms.
Enjoy recreation amenities such as an outdoor pool or take in the view from a rooftop terrace. Additional amenities at this guesthouse include complimentary wireless internet access and wedding services.

Languages

English

Property amenities

Internet

  • Available in some public areas: Free WiFi

Things to do

  • Heated pool
  • Outdoor pool

Guest services

  • No housekeeping service
  • Wedding services

Outdoors

  • Rooftop terrace

Accessibility

  • No elevator

More

  • Smoke-free property

Policies

Check-in

Check-in start time: 3:30 PM; Check-in end time: 9:00 PM
Minimum check-in age: 18

Check-out

Check-out before 12:00 PM

Special check-in instructions

The host will greet guests on arrival
This property is in a car-free zone and can be reached only by a 20-minute ferry from Sayville.
Fire Island Pines is a predominantly LGBTQ community, and often the majority of guests are gay. However, everyone is welcome, regardless of sexual orientation or gender.

Access methods

Host will greet you

Pets

Pets allowed for an extra charge of USD 50.0 per pet, per night

Children and extra beds

This property welcomes adults only

Property payment types

Important information

Optional extras

  • Pet fee: USD 50.0 per pet, per night

The above list may not be comprehensive. Fees and deposits may not include tax and are subject to change.

You need to know

Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy
Government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card, or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges
Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed
This property accepts credit cards

We should mention

This property does not have elevators
This property's policy is to refuse certain bookings for the purpose of group events or parties, including pre-wedding stag/bachelor and hen/bachelorette parties

Property is also known as

Madison Fire Island Pines Guesthouse Sayville
Madison Fire Island Pines Sayville
Guesthouse The Madison Fire Island Pines Sayville
Sayville The Madison Fire Island Pines Guesthouse
The Madison Fire Island Pines Sayville
Madison Fire Island Pines Guesthouse
Madison Fire Island Pines
Guesthouse The Madison Fire Island Pines
Madison Fire Island Pines Sayville
Madison Fire Island Pines Guesthouse Sayville
Guesthouse The Madison Fire Island Pines Sayville
Sayville The Madison Fire Island Pines Guesthouse
The Madison Fire Island Pines Sayville
Madison Fire Island Pines Guesthouse
Guesthouse The Madison Fire Island Pines
Madison Fire Island Pines
Madison Fire Pines Sayville
The Madison Fire Island Pines Sayville
The Madison Fire Island Pines Guesthouse
The Madison Fire Island Pines Guesthouse Sayville

Reviews

8.6

Excellent

Rating 10 - Excellent. 23 out of 40 reviews" "
Rating 8 - Good. 9 out of 40 reviews" "
Rating 6 - Okay. 3 out of 40 reviews" "
Rating 4 - Poor. 4 out of 40 reviews" "
Rating 2 - Terrible. 1 out of 40 reviews" "

8.0/10

Cleanliness

8.6/10

Staff & service

7.8/10

Amenities

8.0/10

Property conditions & facilities

8.4/10

Eco-friendliness

Reviews

6/10 Okay

Michael

Disliked: Cleanliness, staff & service, property conditions & facilities
This is a tough place to review, because there is so little hotel / guesthouse type accommodation here - there are very few options. The Madison is a once top notch property now in bad need of renovations and upgrades, it is in a great location and part of the deal is that Fire Island is exclusive and you have to pay for that, but for $700 a night I would expect a lot better on all levels. Maybe that is just the price here generally, clearly a big opportunity locally for any hotel company - and I gather things are happening. Excellent because the competition should raise standards.
Stayed 5 nights in Aug 2024

8/10 Good

david, Boston

Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service
My room was lovely, but the exterior areas of the property need better upkeep. Pool was never skimmed or cleaned and deck furniture was covered in pine tree droppings.
Stayed 2 nights in Aug 2024

10/10 Excellent

Alan

Stayed 2 nights in Jul 2024

10/10 Excellent

Alex

Traveled with partner
Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, amenities, property conditions & facilities
Stay made the fire island experience all the more fantastic. Mike was an excellent host.
Stayed 3 nights in Jul 2024

10/10 Excellent

Jacob

Traveled with partner
Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, amenities, property conditions & facilities
One of the best in the pines! Will be back, over and over and over again.
Stayed 2 nights in Jun 2024

8/10 Good

Mitchell, New York

Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, amenities, property conditions & facilities
Enjoyable solo stay
Stayed 2 nights in May 2024

8/10 Good

Mason, New York

Traveled with partner, Traveled with pets
Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, property conditions & facilities
Love The Madison! Hope to stay again soon :-)
Stayed 4 nights in Jun 2024

10/10 Excellent

Carla, Brooklyn

Traveled with partner
Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, property conditions & facilities
I loved my stay here! It's a lovely small guest house with a laid back (but highly professional) style. The heated pool is lovely. It's quiet - no piped music; lots of options for breakfast (which is provided); and then an in-room fridge for your own drinks and small snacks. 1 minute from the Ferry, and 1 minute to the Ocean. It's an old school delight.
Stayed 2 nights in May 2024

10/10 Excellent

Yan

Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, amenities, property conditions & facilities
It was perfect trip because of this hotel
Stayed 1 night in May 2024

10/10 Excellent

Daniel

Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, property conditions & facilities, room comfort
Stayed 1 night in May 2024

10/10 Excellent

Daniel

Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, property conditions & facilities, room comfort
Amazing, clean and right in the center of it all.
Mike is an amazing host. His fast and accurate communication helped make the experience. I will stay at the Madison again. From the location to the savory morning breakfast, this is an amazing place to stay.
Stayed 1 night in May 2024

4/10 Poor

Joy, New York, NY

Disliked: Cleanliness, amenities, property conditions & facilities
The GM and AM were nice. The rooms were not clean at all. The towels had stains on them. And the floor was dirty with sand. My AC barely worked and had mold and rust accumulated on it. I understand that the hotel is able to charge an exorbitant rate in the high season and will probably be booked nonetheless but at least upgrade the rooms and sheets/towels to somewhat match the $$$.
Stayed 1 night in Jul 2020

10/10 Excellent

ChrisVuitton, New York, NY

Traveled with group
Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, amenities, property conditions & facilities
We had such an awesome weekend here. The guesthouse is so nice, neat and organized. Thank you to all the staff for your hospitality. You guys made us feel so welcome.
Stayed 1 night in May 2020

8/10 Good

Verified traveler

Liked: Staff & service, amenities
Disliked: Cleanliness
Great location. Great floor plan Great outdoor area. Cleanliness needs improvement; all ceiling fans, window sills and baseboards need vacuuming. Select outdooroven outdoor furniture pieces needs to be replaced
Stayed 3 nights in Oct 2019

10/10 Excellent

Verified traveler

Stayed 1 night in Sep 2019

6/10 Okay

Verified traveler

Stayed 1 night in Sep 2019

10/10 Excellent

Verified traveler

Traveled with group
Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service
Best part about the trip was Angela! Who hosted the stay.
Stayed 1 night in Sep 2019

10/10 Excellent

mark

Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, property conditions & facilities, room comfort
Stayed 1 night in Sep 2019

8/10 Good

Verified traveler

Traveled with partner
Liked: Amenities, property conditions & facilities
Disliked: Cleanliness
Beautiful house. Great location. Breakfast was nice. The floor wasn’t very clean. There was loads of dust on the ceiling fan. The room wasn’t cleaned at all during our three night stay and we weren’t given clean towels and we had to ask for toilet paper. The staff seemed unhappy and they weren’t especially friendly apart from the lady.
Stayed 3 nights in Sep 2019

8/10 Good

Lucy, Nutley Nj

Traveled with group
Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, amenities
Beautiful home with perfect location! Mike was very accommodating and went the extra mile ! When we came back from dinner the home was lite with votive candles which was a very nice trough ! My only disappointment was that some of the cushions in and out of the home needed to be replaced.
Stayed 1 night in Sep 2019

6/10 Okay

Verified traveler

Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service
I liked the pool, the lobby, that it is close to the harbor. The only thing I did not like about my staying was that the toilet was clogged all of the time and we were told to use the toilet on the hallway. I thought it should have been fixed or I should had been given another room.
Stayed 1 night in Sep 2019

10/10 Excellent

Verified traveler

Traveled with group
Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, amenities, property conditions & facilities
Very relaxed environment. Will definitely visit again.
Stayed 1 night in Sep 2019

4/10 Poor

Verified traveler

Traveled with partner
Disliked: Cleanliness, amenities, property conditions & facilities
Sand in our room wasn't cleaned up from previous guests. My boyfriend slipped in the shower (while sober!) and hit his head on the wall - hotel is still charging us for damages.
Stayed 1 night in Sep 2019

8/10 Good

Verified traveler

Traveled with group
Liked: Staff & service, property conditions & facilities, room comfort
Stayed 3 nights in Aug 2019

4/10 Poor

Verified traveler

Traveled with group
Liked: Amenities
Disliked: Cleanliness, staff & service
Look the only reason you pay for the eye watering cost of this place is that it gives you a place to stay in Pines. Simple. So the hotel/guest house has absolutely no incentive to provide more than an average experience for guests. And they even failed to live up to this. The room was really dirty - thick dust everywhere, a bedside clock stuck to the bedside table with muck - all the more exasperated by the fact we were welcomed not with a lovely letter from the owner/manager but a begging letter for tips from housekeeping. Surely when guests are paying $700 dollars a night this is inappropriate. The room also had a few maintenance issues. The bathroom door was would get stuck half way so you had to shimmy around it. There was zero water pressure in the morning so had to shower under a dribble. The bedroom door stopper was lying on the floor and room just generally looking a bit sorry for itself. The beds had the lumpiest pillows made from nasty man made fibre I have ever encountered - I had to sleep with the one throw cushion on the bed. And while we had the “penthouse” room where you expect a little peace and quiet, the other penthouse room next door was connected to our room by same central air system and vents so we could hear every conversation as if they where in the room with us - so terrible design flaw. So even thought I had low expectations these were not even met and I was left feeling disappointed and ripped off. I won’t be back in a hurry
Stayed 2 nights in Aug 2019