Don't have enough good things to say about the Mauian!
My family and I stayed there in July of 2024. The rooms have a 1950s bungalow feel - not "dated", definitely a decor choice. Each room has a small lanai, and robes for the adults. Be aware: there's no TV in the room, but it's Hawaii so if you're sitting in the room, shame on you! Juice and coffee in the morning, drinks and music in the evening. Views to dream of, and plumeria trees right outside your door. Most importantly - less than 50 yards from the stunning beach.
The staff was very accommodating of us. We were travelling with a larger group and our plans changed last minute, forcing us to leave the Mauian before our scheduled checkout. They graciously offered to release us from the remainder of our stay, with no argument.
If you're looking for a classic Hawaii experience - laid back, beach, snorkeling, SUP, etc. this is the place. We'll be returning on our next trip!