We stayed in cabin 9, which appeared to be the only free standing cabin. It was decorated nicely, and had a comfortable campy vibe. Appliances were all clean and in good working condition, bed linens were clean also. We only used one bedroom, the cabin had two. The mattress on the bed was older and a little too firm, but that's a personal preference thing - we still slept just fine. We had no real concerns with the cabin at all.
The property sits on the shore of Black Lake. It has 3 docks, which we enjoyed fishing off of. There's plenty of room for boats as well for people who have them.
The only negative I really have is the price point. We really needed somewhere in the area so we could visit with our daughter, who lives in Alexandria Bay. Because it was Labor Day weekend, everything in ABay was full, we saw this on Orbitz, and took it. The price advertised was fine, but because we were 2 people, not 1, there was a $100 per night charge for an extra person. I have not encountered this situation before when traveling as a couple and bringing no additional family members. We still stayed and found the Lakeside Lodge to be a decent place, but this policy will probably discourage us from staying in the future.