Compare Cheap 3 Star Hotels

"The listing for Cats Cove doesn’t do it justice. The property is meticulously maintained, well appointed and in a perfect location to explore all of Cat Island. Cat and Mark (hosts) were always quick to respond to messages and very helpful throughout our stay. "

"We fell in love with this property and Cat Island! The house is exactly as pictured and described. It was clean and had everything we needed for a week’s stay. If seclusion is what you’re after this is the spot for you! We seen two other people on the beach the entire time we were here. Leslie was an amazing host! She had lots of tips for snorkeling spots and restaurants to grab a bite to eat. We had some storms that knocked out the power, when it came back on we discovered a couple breakers were flipped, Leslie responded quickly and reset everything to get us going again. Will definitely be visiting Pigeon Cay and Sundance again in the future!"

"The most beautiful beach and the views from the house are stunning. We did not see anyone else on the beach for the whole time we were there. It was like a dream."

"Once again, Patti's place did not disappoint. It had everything that we needed for a great stay on Cat Island. Perfect for our kids and adults alike. Will definitely be back again!"

"We had a wonderful time at Rock Hill House. The house and beach are both stunning and in a peaceful part of south Eleuthera. Really appreciated that every bedroom had its own bathroom - it made for excellent privacy for all the guests. The beach is lovely fine sand and there is pretty decent offshore snorkeling - we saw the largest parrot fish that we have EVER seen and we are long time snorkelers. Bring your gear! The tug and barge wrecks just offshore are really cool and remind you of the power of the ocean. The house is showing her age a little - some of the sliding doors don't work and the faucet at the bar. But none of this detracts from this lovely home - it has an elegance that many homes on Eleuthera do not. We did the hike to Lighthouse beach (do it before Disney opens!). Make sure that you drive to Governors Harbor and go to Island Farms - best grocery shopping on the island (fabulous lasagna to go) and great wine prices. Their homemade salad dressings are fantastic. Pam was provided excellent help and Sheila did a lovely job keeping the home clean and tidy. All in all a wonderful stay at our fave island."